Doing quilt mysteries is a risk. Sometimes I love the results, sometimes I don't. Sometimes, if I had seen the quilt ahead of time, I never would have made it, and THAT'S OK! By my thinking, every quilt you make teaches you something.
Sometimes you are forced to do techniques you don't know how to do, you may like it, or you may hate it, but it still teaches you that about yourself. When I do Bonnie Hunter Mysteries, I usually change the colors, but I am very familiar with her quilts, and I've mostly liked my changes. I can only think of one time I wish I hadn't changed the colors. Even on her quilts, I've changed the layout several times.
This is my second year of doing the Murder Mystery Quilt. Last year I had a lot of fun, and although I wasn't thrilled with the final layout, I modified it to be a quilt I like quite a lot. I enjoyed the story and knew who the killer was.
This year I was doubting the quilt less than halfway through the year, I still have no idea who the killer is, and I wasn't thrilled with the layout as I expected. Whether I am buying a pattern, or doing a mystery quilt, I know the final quilt is my own, and I don't see anything wrong with changing a pattern to better suit my taste. Sometimes what I like changes quite a lot based on what is going on in my life. Right now, there is a lot on my mind, a LOT of changes are coming, and I've been attracted to simpler quilts. This year's murder mystery quilt is not simple, and there's nothing wrong with that, but it's not my thing right now. When I saw the layout reveal, I actually debated on splitting the blocks into two quilts, and actually tossing a few blocks, but then I realized I didn't want to do that much extra work on this quilt right now, and if I abandon it, to work on "later" I know I'd never go back to it.
I decided the most efficient way to deal with this, was to finish the quilt center mostly as the designer intended, then change the borders. I felt like there were just too many colors in the quilt, which is weird since I love scrap quilts so much, but with a very scrappy quilt, the colors are distributed all over the quilt, or they are done in gradient or colorwash fashion, something that makes sense to my mind. In this quilt the colors are concentrated in specific areas, and to me, it seems pretty random. I did change the center block, but I used the designers colors, I just used a different block.
I looked through my stash to see if I had any fabrics that had a good number of the colors in it, because to me, the quilt was not cohesive. I found one fabric that had most of the colors in it, but not all of them. It was a busier print than I would have preferred to use, but since it was my only option without shopping, and I'm not shopping for this, it will have to do.
Do I like it? No, I don't. Now that it's together I like it better than when I first saw the reveal, but would I have made the quilt if I had known what it would look like? No. Do I feel like it was a waste of my time? Not really.
The best thing about doing a mystery quilt, especially one that takes place over a full year, is it reminds you to think about the process. I am a prolific quilter, and I can get overly distracted by the finishing, and forget to enjoy the process.
Want to know what I learned while making this quilt? The center block was supposed to be paper pieced, and it was the only block I didn't finish on time. I was going to do the paper pieced block, but I don't enjoy paper piecing, and I couldn't make myself do it. When I totally double downed on NOT doing the paper piecing, I realized that it's not something I'm even remotely interested in getting better at. I CAN paper piece, and if I really loved something I might do it again, but if I never do it again, that's OK with me. I can make a lot of quilts with traditional piecing.
I learned that I am picky about how color is used. I've already mentioned how I almost divided the blocks into two quilts, and tossed a couple blocks. I would have used all the blue blocks in a blue quilt. Sure, I would have added stuff to those blocks to make a whole quilt with them, but it bothers me that the only place blue is used is in the blue blocks.
If I had used the blue blocks in a blue quilt, I would have used most of the other blocks in a green and pink quilt. Sure the center block is only green with white, and the horizontal blocks with concentric squares are only pinks and reds, but with the center border having both pink and green, and the pinwheel blocks and corner blocks having pink and green, they all could work in a cohesive quilt.
So what would I have tossed? I would have eliminated the yellow, and tossed the orange and brown border. Those colors don't integrate into the rest of the quilt.
Do I think the designer did a poor job? NO! The designer was not just designing a quilt, she was telling a story. I know from her explanation of last year's quilt, that every single thing she puts in the quilt means something, from the colors to the block design to the final layout. What seems random to me, was very intentional on her part.
I'm taking a break from mystery quilts for a while, I've just got too much on my plate to keep trying to work them in. At least with the quilt top done this quilt will eventually work its way to the top of the quilting queue, and it won't be a UFO forever.